WWYD 2015-09-14

[or2az]

Edited by moderator: This post is split from this other WWYD: viewtopic.php?f=49&t=52933

I had a similar hand today, which presented the same kind of problem, which is why I went searching for a WWYD.
Again, 5 pairs, rest of the hand well connected, and still not sure which way to go, especially with North tempting me with that discard for an open toi-toi. Should probably resist.
Would like to hear your opinions on both of these situations, my new one, and maybe a fresh look at that 4 year old WWYD.
Consider if that yakuhai dora 3 pung of 9-cracks weren't there, how would that change your opinion? Or would it?

phpR6WHcnAM.jpg (33.47 KiB) Viewed 9314 times

[Mauro]

I wouldn't pon : I'd prefer to be able to defend better, and I don't like the idea of starting toitoi so late in the game without triplets; I would remain open for chii toitsu, which is nice, and if I draw or I'm tenpai (albeit I'm not sure I'd riichi, with one and one in the ponds it's a bad wait; drawing I wouldn't, since I would already have a yaku).

[or2az]

Good plan. I didn't really intend this hand as a wwyd but rather as an illustration comparing two situations, each with 5 pairs, where in one of them, the goal and choice of discard seemed a lot more definitive than in the other. It was mentioned that 5 people chose "other" as a discard in the original and obviously, that strong mangan potential by South was also present and probably had a lot to do with the wide variety of discard choices, and why I was finding it difficult.
I was also curious about if that mangan potential was not there, and the situation was more in line with my similar illustration, how the choice of discard might have changed. I assume this wasn't obvious so the post was split. No problem.