
http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2010072116gm-0 ... &tw=1&ts=1
Moderator: Shirluban
I have RECORDED my Junsei Chuuren!Goldeneye wrote:Whoa, you made a Chuuren Poutou? I've not really been close to that hand myself in many thousand hands of riichi mahjong (including the days of original Yakuman of 2-player riichi mahjong for the Game Boy)!
I doubt that yours was the Junsei version (waiting on any tile of that suit that is).
I am equally surprised you actually haven't made Kokushi Musou!
Because every time a club member was close to achieving chuuren, it always had been in souzu.Referee wrote:"It had to happen some day, and it had to happen with Sou". Why did it have to happen with Sou?
Nope. That's Double Riichi + Ippatsu. (And ouch)Xa0s wrote:A quick question. If the dealer makes double riichi at his first discard
and the south player deals immediately his wining tile.Is it a Renho Yakuman or not ???
Isn't that a a little bit unfair??Kyuu wrote:Nope. That's Double Riichi + Ippatsu. (And ouch)Xa0s wrote:A quick question. If the dealer makes double riichi at his first discard
and the south player deals immediately his wining tile.Is it a Renho Yakuman or not ???
Renho applies to non-dealers, where that first discard is the win.
For Tenhou, Chihou, Renhou -- tenpai must exist before any tile is drawn or discarded. In the case of Tenhou, the dealer wins before anything happens. So, the fact that the dealer had to drop something in order to get tenpai... that already disqualifies the condition.
Considering that renhou isn't ever used (especially as a yakuman) anymore, with the exception of some beginner-oriented mahjong games, no.Xa0s wrote:Isn't that a a little bit unfair??Kyuu wrote:Nope. That's Double Riichi + Ippatsu. (And ouch)Xa0s wrote:A quick question. If the dealer makes double riichi at his first discard
and the south player deals immediately his wining tile.Is it a Renho Yakuman or not ???
Renho applies to non-dealers, where that first discard is the win.
For Tenhou, Chihou, Renhou -- tenpai must exist before any tile is drawn or discarded. In the case of Tenhou, the dealer wins before anything happens. So, the fact that the dealer had to drop something in order to get tenpai... that already disqualifies the condition.
ex. The North player will have the opportunity to go out from 3 discard and a shelf Draw.
And considering that East draws 14 tiles and discards one ..he can claim that he is in tenpai from the beginning.